Comparison between capacitive and resistive electronic transfer therapy and high-intensity laser therapy in pain conditions related to musculoskeletal disorders

ABSTRACT Introduction: Musculoskeletal disorders (MSDs) imply damage to muscular or skeletal systems, which usually develop due to strenuous, repetitive activity, or an inflammation process. The therapy with capacitive and resistive electronic transfer (CRet) and high-intensity laser therapy (HILT) have mainly been applied for pain relief in these conditions. This paper aims to provide an overview of the efficient results of CRet therapy and HILT in managing pain associated with musculoskeletal disorders found in the available literature. Methods: Articles related to musculoskeletal disorders were searched through electronic databases, such as PubMed, Web of Knowledge, Lilacs, Cochrane, Research Gate, and available website search tools. After excluding records that are not clinical trials and studies (such as review articles, patient information, and Ph.D. papers) and articles which did not deal with pain in musculoskeletal disorders, 61 articles met our criteria and were included in the overview. Results: By reviewing the selected articles related to CRet therapy and HILT effects on pain in musculoskeletal disorders, it was found that both therapies have a favorable effect on pain reduction. Conclusion: The selected papers showed that both therapies are powerful tools for pain reduction. Although there are no specific protocols, including the number and frequency of therapies applied and other parameters, in both therapy modalities, pain alleviation occurs during or immediately after a therapy cycle application.

Experimental study: therapeutic application of Tecartherapy in cervical algic syndrome

Tecartherapy applied to patients suffering from cervical algic syndrome is able to induce a recovery in neck mobility and to significantly reduce pain, not only in the immediate post-treatment period, but also long-term, as demonstrated by the results of the study after a two-months follow-up.
Abstract About 2/3 of the population have at least one episode of cervicalgia in their lifetime. It is estimated that the chronicity occurs in 10% of the subjects. The definition of "cervical pain syndrome" indicates a pain in the posterior region of the neck, more precisely in the area between the upper nuchal line and the horizontal line passing through the spines of the scapula; the pain, which can be felt monolaterally or bilaterally, is almost always accompanied by reflexed muscular contractions, with consequent stiffness of the neck joint. A sample of 20 patients was evaluated before and after the treatment with Tecartherapy and at 2 months of follow-up, using the "Neck Pain Questionnaire" (NPQ) and the "Numerical rating Scale" (NRS) for pain assessment. On average, the NRS value falls from 6.63 to 2.70 after treatment, and to 2.55 at follow-up. The NPQ value also decreases sharply, from 37.95% to 16.67% after treatment, and to 12.54% at the two-months followup. The results highlight the efficacy of Tecartherapy even in pathologies which are not of strictly sport origin, with a marked improvement in symptoms and a stable result over time, up to the two months of follow-up.
Source: G. Raffaetà et al, Studio sperimentale: applicazione terapeutica della tecarterapia nelle sindromi algiche cervicali, EUROPA MEDICOPHYSICA, 2007; 43, suppl.1 to No. 3 © Minerva Medica

Randomized double-blind Tecartherapy versus placebo in the treatment of lower back pain

In patients suffering from chronic, exacerbted, low back pain, the treatment with Tecartherapy has an immediate effect on pain reduction, decreasing the probability of incurring in complications due to immobility and non-use, as well as being able to work completely from the first moments of rehabilitation.
Abstract Introduction. TECAR therapy (TTp) is a form of physical therapy acting at the level of tissue metabolism. The theoretical operating principle is the production of endogenous heat starting from the extracorporeal application of an oscillating magnetic field. The TECAR therapy treatment involves the synergy of the action of physical energy with the common methods of manual therapy (pompages, mobilization, massage therapy, etc.) and is used in acute and chronic osteoarticular diseases. Although patients and nurses commonly report an optimal response in terms of rapid pain reduction, there is currently no scientific evidence to clearly demonstrate its efficacy. The objective of the present work is therefore to evaluate the efficacy of TTp in a group of patients suffering from chronic low back pain. Materials and methods. 30 patients of both sexes with chronic exacerbated pain (VAS ≥ 5 in the last week) aged between 30 and 65 years were randomized into 2 groups: group A (TTp plus Massotherapy: 8 sessions 3 per week); group B (Placebo - switched off device - plus Massotherapy: 8 sessions 3 per week). The treatments of the 2 groups were carried out by the same physiotherapist. The evaluation was performed by an evaluating doctor, blinded to the treatment assigned. The following scales were used for the evaluation: VAS scale for pain assessment; Roland and Morris Disability Questionnaire to study the degree of disability; EUROQoL for the evaluation of the quality of life. Clinical checks were performed before treatment, at the fifth (T2) and at the last treatment session (T3), at 3 months (T4) and at 6 months (T5) after the end of treatment. Results. Preliminary results indicate for patients in group A a greater efficacy in the management of middle-grade pain with a significant decrease in its perception in short-term controls.
Source: P. Stagi et al, Studio clinico randomizzato in doppio cieco: tecarterapia versus placebo nel trattamento della lombalgia, MEDICAPHYSICA EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF PHYSICAL AND REHABILITATION MEDICINE, 2008;44 (Suppl.1 to No. 3) © Minerva Medica

Cervicalgia, lumbago, sciatica: application of capacitive energy transfer system

Chronic diseases are often difficult to treat with traditional methods. In this study the patients, after being unsuccessfully submitted to different treatments, thanks to Tecartherapy mentioned a remarkable improvement of symptoms in 65% of cases, immediately after the treatment session.
Abstract For this study, we selected a total of 23 patients sent from the Rehabilitation Unit of the University of Valladolid Hospital with diagnoses of simple lumbago, lumbosciatica, cervicalgia, and cervicobrachialgia after treatment with non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs and conventional electrotherapy was unsuccessful. At the Centre, all were treated with the Capacitive Energy Transfer system. In this study, we describe the protocol of the treatment, diagnostic parameters, clinical course of development, and results obtained.
Keywords: Lumbosciatica, cervicobrachialgia, cervicalgia
Source: A. Molina et al, Cervicali, lombalgie, sciatalgie: applicazione del sistema a trasferimento energetico capacitivo, Evidenze cliniche, Tecar, Unibell ed. settembre 2003, pp. 65-68 © 2003 Unibell International

TECAR therapy for Peyronie’s disease: a phase-one prospective study. Great evidence in patients with erectile dysfunction

In this study, there is evidence of the effectiverness of TECAR therapy in the treatment of pain in Peyronie’s disease. The treatment not only showed an evident effeciveness, but also its extreme tolerability and absence of adverse effects. Patients with erectile dysfunctions, moreover, reported an improvement in sexual potency.
Abstract Our phase-one prospective study wants to evaluate the safety and tolerability of TECAR therapy in the treatment of Peyronie’s disease. From June 2011 to September 2012 we enrolled 70 patients. Each patient had been previously subjected to andrological examination, to a questionnaire for the evaluation of IPP and ED, and the SF-36 (V1) for the evaluation of the general state of health. The evaluation of pain was made using the VAS scale of pain. Every patient was subjected to TECAR treatment of the fibrotic plaque (both in resistive mode and in capacitive mode) for a total of three sessions carried out on consecutive days. We recorded a good compliance by patients; none of them reported side effects. Pain was decreased by the technique in 80% of the cases. The whole sample completed the study. Surprisingly enough those patients who complained also of erectile dysfunction, reported an improvement in sexual potency.
Keywords: Erectile dysfunction, Peyronie’s disease, TECAR
Source: C. Pavone et al, Il Trasferimento Energetico Capacitivo Resistivo (TECAR) nella terapia dell’Induratio Penis Plastica: studio pilota di fase uno sulla tollerabilità, sulla sicurezza e sull’applicabilità della tecnica. Quali altri risvolti sorprendenti? Urologia 2013; 80(2): 148- 53 © 2013 Wichtig Editore

Role of FKT in the management of anterior knee pain. Confirmations and new insights

TECAR therapy in useful for the treatment of pain in patellofemoral jount syndrome, among other therapies and it can avoid the need of surgery for a number of patients.
Abstract The etiology of patellofemoral joint syndrome is multifactorial. Treatment is often conservative and successful. The rehabilitative program consists of exercises to increase VMO and quadriceps strength and to improve flexibility of the hamstrings, vastus lateralis and iliotibial band. Ultrasound, laser and TECAR therapy may decrease painful symptoms. Surgery should be reserved for patients with an unsuccessful six months’ conservative treatment.
Source: F.Di Domenica & L.Volonté, Il ruolo della fisiochinesiterapia nel dolore anteriore. Conferme e novità, Archivio di Ortopedia e Reumatologia, 2008; 119(1): 25–26 © Springer-Verlag Italia 2008

Osteoarticular pain in geriatric patients: Treatment with capacitive energy transfer system

The results obtained by treating geriatric subjects with osteoarticular pain show a noticeable improvement in most patients, until a complete disappearance of the pain. The treatment is also easily combined with other therapeutic means.
Abstract: This study was conducted on 214 patients with joint pain, functional disability and muscular rigidity treated with the Capacitive Energy Transfer system. The results obtained revealed a significant improvement in 62 percent of the cases, that is, an improvement that was maintained as a stable condition over time. The evaluation was performed subjectively by the patient and verified by the physiotherapist and physician.
Keywords: Osteoarticular pain in the elderly pathology
Source: J.R. Bordas Serrat & D. Martinez, Dolore osteoarticolare in geriatria: trattamento con il sistema a trasferimento energetico capacitivo